Dispute Resolution

“Marini Pietrantoni Muñiz’s team has great expertise and handles… matters in an excellent manner. Their responsiveness and service are excellent.”

– Chambers & Partners, Latin America 2023

Our approach is proactive and responsible. We prepare each case from the start as if it were to go to trial, yet always strive to reach the most cost-efficient, practical and strategic result our clients expect. We try our clients’ cases in all courts and forums in Puerto Rico at the federal, state, and administrative levels, both as plaintiffs and defendants, and all throughout the appellate process as well as in arbitration and mediation proceedings.

 

We litigate bet-the-company and high-profile matters in multiple areas of the law and represent clients in all industries of the Puerto Rico market, including Antitrust, Banking and Finance, Commercial Leasing, Construction, Contracts, Data Privacy and Cyber Security, Derivative Suits, Distribution and Franchising, Energy, First Amendment, Fraud, General Business matters, Healthcare, Insurance, Intellectual Property, Manufacturing, Personal Injury, Premises Liability, Products Liability, Securities and Trade Secrets. Our clients include multinational companies, Fortune 500 companies, national and local high net-worth companies, and high net-worth individuals, all of which are leaders in their respective fields.

 

Our trial matters have included a 500 million dollar portfolio of over eighty cases representing victims of Hurricane María against all insurance companies in Puerto Rico, multiple Mass Tort cases representing an industrial janitorial services company against claims brought due to a bacteria outbreak in a hospital, Multi-Million Dollar Dealer termination disputes representing both suppliers and dealers, Highly Publicized First Amendment defense matters representing television, radio, and print media companies, Construction defects in an international airport runway representing the airport operator, Commercial Leasing disputes representing the landlord, Environmental disputes representing a global energy company, Intellectual Property disputes representing a leading solar power energy company in Puerto Rico, Lender Liability claims representing banks, Real Estate disputes representing the largest hotel developer in Puerto Rico, and many others. Our litigators have also defended clients in multiple high stakes securities matters, including Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) Arbitrations, Government Investigations, Enforcement Actions, Class Actions, and Derivative Suits.


We look forward to serving you. Learn more about our practice areas below.

Expertise and capabilities

Overview

We focus on a strategic approach to legal services by rendering efficient, practical, and thorough legal advice, and aggressively try cases to judgment, when necessary, to protect our clients’ business interests and needs. Our mission is simple: achieve the best possible result for our clients. Whether it’s trying a case to verdict and until the final appeal is decided, or negotiating a settlement in or out of court, our lawyers work tirelessly to serve our clients’ interests and reach their desired result.

Antitrust & Trade Regulation

MPM’s dedicated team of legal professionals is committed to guiding clients through the complex landscape of antitrust laws and trade regulations to protect their business interests. From merger reviews and acquisitions to antitrust investigations and litigation, we offer strategic advice and representation tailored to each client’s unique needs. Whether clients are seeking to expand their market presence, defend against allegations of anticompetitive behavior, or resolve disputes with competitors, our team has the knowledge and expertise to guide them through every stage of the legal process.

 

As businesses face increasing scrutiny from regulatory authorities, competitors, and consumers, our experienced attorneys provide comprehensive counsel to help clients understand and comply with antitrust laws, ensuring fair competition, and preventing potential violations.

 

MPM handles private antitrust litigation across all aspects, from managing class actions and multidistrict litigations to litigating individual actions in a single jurisdiction. Our litigators see the broader picture and adeptly handle the intersection between antitrust law and other areas, including securities and intellectual property, to devise creative and holistic solutions. We also have prepared and provided seminars to clients (and their salesforce) regarding the do’s and don’ts to protect thec clients’ businesses and avoid antitrust scrutiny or potential liability.

Appellate Practice

MPM’s appellate practice is dedicated to providing exceptional representation in complex appellate cases. Our team comprises highly experienced attorneys who have briefed and argued high-profile cases before both state and federal appellate courts. We bring together some of the most skilled and persuasive legal writers and litigators in Puerto Rico. Additionally, many of our attorneys have served as judicial clerks at the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico and the Puerto Rico Court of Appeals, further enhancing our firm’s appellate expertise.

 

Our appellate practice handles high-stakes, precedent-setting appeals across a broad range of subjects, including antitrust, bankruptcy, defamation, First Amendment issues, insurance, professional liability, securities, mass torts, and various constitutional matters.

 

MPM’s appellate team is prepared to guide clients through the appellate process with a meticulous approach to legal research, detailed record analysis, and an emphasis on preserving key arguments for appeal. We leverage deep expertise across the firm’s diverse, industry-leading practice areas to develop compelling written briefs and deliver powerful, persuasive oral arguments. At the trial stage, we draw on our appellate experience to advise clients on critical strategic decisions and to craft and argue dispositive motions with a keen focus on positioning for potential appeals.

 

MPM’s appellate practice is built on a commitment to excellence, diligence, and strategic thinking. Whether pursuing or defending an appeal, our goal is to protect our clients’ interests, achieve favorable outcomes, and shape the development of law through our advocacy.

Dealer & Franchise

MPM has a leading dealer and franchise practice, not just for dispute resolution, but also consulting. We represent across all industries both international and national manufacturers and suppliers, and local dealers; as well as international and national franchisors, and local franchisees. Our hands-on experience representing both positions gives us a unique advantage over competing firms, and provides us with a keen understanding of the needs of all the parties involved. Whether it is a dealer and franchise matter under Law 75 (Puerto Rico’s dealer and franchise statute) or a sales representative matter under Law 21 (Law 75’s sister statute protecting sales representatives), our lawyers possess the necessary in-depth knowledge and experience to represent all types of clients. 

 

Related publications include:

 

  • “Lessons to be Learned from Puerto Rico’s Law 75” – The Franchise Lawyer, Vol. 17, No. 3 (ABA Summer 2014)
  • “Puerto Rico’s Dealer and Franchise Statute Adapts to the Latest Developments in Law, Commerce, and Technology” – Franchise Law Journal, Vol. 30, No. 1 (ABA Summer 2010)
  • “Forum Selection Clauses under the Puerto Rico Dealer Statute: Is the Statute’s Provision invalidating such Clauses still Enforceable?”  – The Business Suit, DRI Newsletter (July 2008)
  • “Internet sales that affect Exclusivity Rights of Puerto Rico Dealers and Sales Representatives” – P.R. Chamber of Commerce (February 2008)
  • “Unbranded or generic products sold to distributors in Puerto Rico: are distributors reselling such products protected by the Puerto Rico Dealers’ Act?” – The Business Suit, DRI, Newsletter (June 2007)  

First Amendment

MPM has a robust First Amendment practice that garners interest from print, television, and radio media companies alike. It represents clients in all three major news and entertainment broadcast forums. Its clients include Publi-Inversiones Puerto Rico, Inc., Spanish Broadcasting Service Corp., and Telemundo of Puerto Rico, Inc., principally defending against defamation claims and other First Amendment matters. In 2024, for instance, MPM represented El Vocero, one of the major newspapers in Puerto Rico, and obtained a landmark victory where the Puerto Rico Supreme Court, for the first time, held that the reporter’s privilege applies in Puerto Rico, thus recognizing a journalist’s qualified right to protect the identity of confidential sources. 

Intellectual Property

MPM has a highly regarded intellectual property practice group, who serve our clients with their intellectual property needs in Puerto Rico, the United States and internationally. Our team handles all aspects of intellectual property matters, from the registration and protection of trademarks in the Puerto Rico Trademark Registry and the United States Patent and Trademark Office, the registration of copyrights in the United States Copyright Office, to litigating matters of trademark, copyright and patent infringement. We are able to advance our clients’ interests at every stage, from risk mitigation and avoidance, to compliance monitoring, pre-suit assessments, rights enforcement, trial and appeal. MPM attorneys have litigated IP matters across the state and federal courts, as well as the United States Patent and Trademark Office (Trademark Trial and Appeal Board) and the United States International Trade Commission.

 

Our IP services include: (i) intellectual property counseling and opinions; (ii) trademark, copyright and branding; (iii) intellectual property (trademark and copyright) registration and licensing; and (iv) intellectual property litigation.

Securities, Litigation & Enforcement

MPM attorneys have defended clients in multiple high stakes securities matters. While prepared to take cases to trial or final hearing, we pride ourselves in reaching favorable and early results. In keeping with our firm’s mission, we strive to achieve the best possible results for our clients.

 

Our practice areas include:

 

  • Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) Arbitration
  • Government Investigations
  • Enforcement Actions

 

Our attorneys have represented clients in different securities matters, including class actions, derivative suits, and individual arbitration claims. We have represented broker-dealers and financial institutions in different administrative and investigative proceedings before the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), as well as in securities’ related discovery before governmental agencies in formal and informal investigations. We have also represented clients before the state and federal courts in Puerto Rico in securities related litigations, as well as in multiple individual arbitration claims filed before FINRA.

 

Representative subject areas include, among others, claims alleging misrepresentation, fraud, unsuitability, churning, unauthorized transactions, supervision, and product failure.

Sports & Entertainment

MPM attorneys represent professional and amateur athletes, as well as sports and talent agencies and media companies in a wide variety of matters. We have represented clients in matters regarding sports and media rights, image and brand counseling and protection, as well as other commercial transactions involving talent, sponsorship and licensing deals. We have also represented clients in sports and entertainment related litigation.

“Noted disputes practice with a strong track record representing clients in civil, commercial and bankruptcy litigation cases.”

– Chambers & Partners, Latin America Guide, 2020

“Experience litigating at the federal level… very recognized in this field.”

– Chambers & Partners, Latin America Guide, 2018

“Bolsters the litigation practice…”

– Chambers & Partners, Latin America Guide

“…understands what we have to go through when dealing with complex commercial litigation matters.”

– Chambers & Partners, Latin America Guide, 2019

“With Marini Pietrantoni Muñiz, we have won every single case we have brought to the table. Its team does not waste time or resources.”

– Chambers & Partners, Latin America Guide, 2024

“Manuel Pietrantoni is a highly competent and knowledgeable lawyer. He is an exemplary litigator.”

– Chambers & Partners, Latin America Guide, 2024

“MPM’s team has demonstrated an unwavering commitment to protecting our interests. Their professionalism and ethical standards have solidified my trust in The Firm.”

– Chambers & Partners, Latin America Guide, 2024

Experience

Our team has a deep bench with vast experience in different practice areas and has been at the forefront of landmark cases across varios sectors.

 

  • In mass tort litigation, MPM represents the largest janitorial services company of Puerto Rico being sued by hundreds of plaintiffs in multiple matters claiming millions of dollars in damages for the deaths of hundreds of people due to a bacteria outbreak in a hospital where MPM’s client performs its services. MPM has secured wins in all matters except one that is still pending.

 

  • MPM’s client purchased multi-million dollar interest in dozens of complaints against insurance companies owned by insured entities that suffered catastrophic damages from hurricanes. MPM serves as lead trial counsel. Insurance companies filed over 60 motions to dismiss the complaints alleging that the assignment agreements through which the policyholders assigned fee simple title to an undivided interest in each of the claims were invalid under the insurance policy. Sixty appeals ultimately reached the Puerto Rico Supreme Court, resulting in the issuance of two ground-breaking decisions upholding the validity of the post-loss assignment agreement issued in favor of MPM’s client. In these same matters, the insurance companies filed dozens of appeals arguing that the retroactive application of a law that allows the insureds to request valuation of their claimed damages through an appraisal process was unconstitutional. The Supreme Court issued another ground-breaking decision in favor of MPM’s clients determining that the law in question applied retroactively to the claims related to the hurricanes at issue.

 

  • MPM represents the highest circulated newspaper in Puerto Rico in a defamation suit brought by a former Director of the Tourism Company of Puerto Rico, alleging that the newspaper published a defamatory column accusing him of sexual misconduct against female employees. MPM is lead counsel defending the newspaper under First Amendment free speech and freedom of the press grounds. In a landmark decision by the Puerto Rico Supreme Court, MPM was successful in arguing that the reporter’s privilege applies in Puerto Rico.

 

  • MPM represents a principal law firm in Puerto Rico against the company shareholder of an international bank that brought a derivative suit against MPM’s client alleging fraud and professional malpractice. The matter is pending in federal court.

 

  • MPM represents the operator of Puerto Rico’s international airport in a multi-million-dollar construction defects complaint involving an asphalt renovation project on an airport taxiway that had to be closed off as an unusable unit of work. The matter is pending in state court.

 

  • MPM represented the largest hotel developer in Puerto Rico against a large group of would-be protesters and land occupiers that sought to invade the beach site of the most luxurious hotel in Puerto Rico to disrupt business operations in order to gain traction to revoke certain land permits regarding the territorial limits of the development.

 

  • MPM has represented multiple financial institutions and broker dealers in over one hundred arbitrations before the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) and court cases related, among other matters, to the Puerto Rico bond market downturn, as well as enforcement actions and investigations before the federal and local regulatory authorities.

 

  • MPM represents one of the most prominent global air conditioning and refrigeration manufacturers in a dispute against a local distributor who claimed millions of dollars in damages under Puerto Rico Dealer’s Act (Law 75). The federal court granted summary judgment in favor of MPM’s client, dismissing all claims and the multimillion claim for damages. The appeal is pending before the First Circuit Court of Appeals.

Market Recognition

Our team has received widespread market recognition for their experience and service to clients.

 

Our trial and appellate lawyers are leaders in their field and have been recognized by the Latin America and Global editions of Chambers & Partners® for dispute resolution, by Best Lawyers® as top litigators in Puerto Rico, by Legal 500, and by Law Dragon. Chambers & Partners® ranks our firm as Band 1 for dispute resolution, the highest ranking possible, both in its Latin America and Global editions. 

 

Our lawyers include a faculty member of the “Building Trial Skills” program of the National Institute for Trial Advocacy (NITA) that was held in Puerto Rico, a former member of a selection committee formed by the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico to recommend a magistrate judge, a member of the CJA committee of the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico, a former President and current Directors of the Puerto Rico Chapter of the Federal Bar Association, a fellow of the American Bar Association, a fellow of the Federal Bar Association, a former board member of the Intellectual Property Commission of the Puerto Rico Bar Association, and members of the Federal Bar Association, and the American Bar Association, among others.

Publications & Seminars

Our lawyers have contributed or published leading industry articles on numerous topics relevant to our practice areas and expertise.

 

  • “Lessons to be Learned from Puerto Rico’s Law 75” – The Franchise Lawyer, Vol. 17, No. 3 (ABA Summer 2014)

 

  • “Fraud, Intent of the Parties, Ambiguity, and Other Exceptions to the Parol Evidence Rule” – Franchise Law Journal, Vol. 31, No. 3 (ABA Winter 2012)

 

  • “Puerto Rico’s Dealer and Franchise Statute Adapts to the Latest Developments in Law, Commerce, and Technology” – Franchise Law Journal, Vol. 30, No. 1 (ABA Summer 2010)

 

  • “Forum Selection Clauses under the Puerto Rico Dealer Statute: Is the Statute’s Provision invalidating such Clauses still Enforceable?”  – The Business Suit, DRI Newsletter (July 2008)

 

  • “Internet sales that affect Exclusivity Rights of Puerto Rico Dealers and Sales Representatives” – P.R. Chamber of Commerce (February 2008)

 

  • “Unbranded or generic products sold to distributors in Puerto Rico: are distributors reselling such products protected by the Puerto Rico Dealers’ Act?” – The Business Suit, DRI, Newsletter (June 2007)